|
Last week
we defined a few chapters in the U.S. Bankruptcy Code. Now,
let's see how these chapters affect us as investors in U.S.
companies?
We learned
chapter 7 is used for complete liquidation of personal, corporate,
or business partnership assets. In the business arena, this
chapter is used to terminate the corporation or partnership.
When we learn a business is filing Chapter 7, it's usually
on the same day they close their doors. There could be hints
and signs leading up to this extreme measure. The stock may
waffle up and down, and there may be rumors about "complete
company overhaul" or "we're working on our books." Any of
these actions may be an indicator, or they may be sincere
attempts to reorganize. There's just no way to tell, and the
company surely isn't going to announce a decision to terminate
business anytime before they actually cease to operate.
Most likely,
the corporation or partnership involved in chapter 7 will
close its doors upon the advice of their attorney(s). Then,
we - as investors - will receive notice as creditors to this
business. Chapter 7 places a 'stay' against all collectors
for terminal businesses, and - as long as that stay is in
effect - our hands are tied from collecting what we feel is
owed us.
We - as
unsecured creditors - are unable to hassle corporate executives
or make a general nuisance of ourselves to collect what we
feel is owed us when a business declares straight bankruptcy.
In addition, we cannot initiate any lawsuits, or place telephone
calls demanding payment. Chapter 7 grants this protection
to corporations and partnerships when they can't pay debts.
An unsecured
creditor doesn't have collateral material that was documented
to retrieve as repayment for the debt owed. We may have equity,
but it's not secure. Secured creditors are those who have
property or other items owed to them as collateral for loans
made to corporations and partnerships. Unsecured creditors
usually wait in the back of the line for payment, if any is
left after secured creditors are paid.
If you
remember from last week, the court appoints a trustee to the
business in the process of filing chapter 7. This trustee
is the person we contact with questions. Within forty days
after a petition for chapter 7 is filed, we will receive notice
of a "meeting of creditors," and it will probably come from
the trustee. This notice is important, as we're one of those
creditors.
The business
(debtor) will appear at this meeting, and we can ask questions
regarding financial affairs and property. The trustee will
also appear at this meeting, and the debtor must supply documents
and answers for anything the trustee requests. Often, we will
be allowed to have a proxy stand in for us at the meetings
to ask questions and to procure information if we can't attend.
The bankruptcy judge will not be in attendance, in order to
preserve independent judgment for the actual court date.
The appointed
trustee is charged with impartiality. The trustee's main function
is to assess the debtor's property, including debts and assets,
and to liquidate the non-exempt assets. Exempt assets would
be those the debtor can refinance to maintain for personal
use. Some states actually have their own laws about what a
debtor can exempt from chapter 7 liquidation, so be sure to
check their state laws about what can and cannot be made exempt
to clear up debts. Most corporations and partnerships may
not have the luxury of claiming any exempt materials. Business
laws for both business setups often protect the individuals
involved in running both the corporation and the partnership,
and it also often protects their individual assets.
It could
take years for the trustee to liquidate assets, and for secured
creditors to feel satisfied with repayment. What does this
mean for us as investors? It means - most likely - we can
kiss our investment money goodbye.
Possibly,
the only recourse is a class-action lawsuit. Often, these
suits - if justified - could take even more years to settle.
The proof would be in whether the corporation or partnership
as an entity actually committed financial criminal acts within
their accounting procedures. Even if a person or the corporation
or partnership was indicted, one would wonder where the money
would come from to pay us off - and how many pennies we would
receive on each dollar invested.
Within
the past two years, we learned we aren't safe from major corporate
bankruptcy. Most corporations try to reorganize through chapter
11 restructuring. This latter move is heartening in that we
realize the company intends to keep operating through rough
waters. However, there may come a time when we wake up one
morning to the realization that what we once prized has gone
"poof" and disappeared.
Before
a chapter 7 disrupts our lives, it's best to reevaluate our
investment procedures. If you're like me, you don't have a
lot to invest, and a loss of a couple hundred dollars - let
alone a few thousand - would be heartbreaking. My grandmother
was fond of saying, "Don't put all your eggs in one basket."
However, if you can only afford one egg, you don't have a
choice; unless, of course, you divide that egg up into several
investment possibilities with a BUYandHOLD investment strategy.
Next week
we'll look at chapter 11, and see how we might benefit from
this move in the market.
Until
then,
Linda Goin
|