|
When a
corporation or partnership declares Chapter 7 in the U.S.
bankruptcy courts, it doesn't leave much of a leg for the
investor to stand on throughout this process. However, several
other bankruptcy procedures aren't as debilitating for the
investor.
One of
the support systems available to investors is called the Securities
Investor Protection Act (SIPA), which created the Securities
Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC) in 1970. The SIPC is
a nonprofit organization funded by member brokerage firms,
and designed to protect securities held by individual brokerages
belonging to this organization.
This organization
is very specific about what is secured and not secured in
SIPA liquidations. Oh, that nasty word again - liquidation
is what SIPA is all about, but it's one that takes a slightly
different track from a Chapter 7. In this case, the SIPC protects
stocks and bonds held by a financially troubled brokerage,
but not exactly the same way the FDIC (Federal Deposit Insurance
Corporation) would protect our savings at the local bank.
The SIPC
insurance coverage on stocks and bonds is not the same as
insurance coverage by the FDIC because investments aren't
the same as savings. It would be in our best interest to read
more about the SIPC at
their website. The site is easy, fairly straightforward,
and Cora breezed through the little quiz included on their
site. Within fifteen minutes, she learned how her investments
at BUYandHOLD are protected through the SIPC. They're protected,
because BUYandHOLD is a division of Freedom Investments, a
member of the SIPC.
In another
area of interest: If we decide to invest in municipalities
through bonds or other issue, we might want to check state
laws regarding possible Chapter 9 filings. The history of
Chapter 9 is rather convoluted, and varies by state and even
by county. Some issues are valid in Colorado, others are valid
in Connecticut, and others are valid in California. No matter
what we might invest in through a municipal fund or bond,
it's wise to at least become a bit familiar with what might
be constituted as a municipality in our area or the area of
investment, and what can be protected through filing reorganization
through Chapter 9.
Reorganization
is mostly a sincere attempt to avoid liquidation of assets
and an end to business as usual. Chapter 11 is usually the
route most businesses take to avoid liquidation when financial
troubles arise. This is not to say that Chapter 11 is a cure-all
for a poorly run business. It is, however, a great signal
to closely watch a company as they dig out from under a possible
ruinous financial situation.
We've
seen many large corporate entities suffer through Chapter
11 within the past two years. Some businesses sought government
support, and others quietly manage to dig their way out by
serious downsizing and whittling away at their resources to
increase the bottom line. If we're caught in the investment
angle with a company filing Chapter 11, what do we do?
Possibly
the best thing to do is follow the company's line of thought
as they make their way through the quagmire of bad debt. Many
times we might see a complete change of the board, or of the
operating CEOs. We might also see a complete revamp of the
product lines or service areas and policies. We have three
choices if we've already committed our dollars to investment:
sell, hold, or buy more. What we do is entirely up to us.
I had
a friend who was fond of saying, "No sense throwing good money
after bad." In plain English, he meant the best action in
a failing industry would be to pull out while the pulling
was still good. However, this isn't always the case in the
investment of a company filing Chapter 11. The best scenario
might be one where we wait to see if the company finds their
footing, as some good companies often fall during national
economic downturns. What may seem "bad money" today might
be the flawless gem next year, especially if they can pick
themselves up, dust themselves off, and start all over again.
One possible
warning sign is to watch for is a court order requiring a
trustee to be involved with company reorganization in Chapter
11. This may mean the company might be suspect with fraud,
incompetence, misconduct, or any other mismanagement or irregularity
in past business procedures. This may mean a setback in timing
the reorganization to best benefit the public relations of
the company. PR is important in Chapter 11 - the fast and
clean reorganization with a solid plan for the future seems
to maintain a better chance of investor interest. This fast
and clean reorganization also increases the value of the company's
equities because of that investor involvement.
Also watch
for wildly fluctuating stock movements when new boards, CEOs,
and policies are incorporated in a reorganization plan. If
we're already invested, and it seems the company (and the
economy) might see a light at the end of the tunnel, it could
behoove us to keep the faith and keep investing in this company's
equities. A good company turn-around is difficult to manage;
however, if done well, the company and our portfolio may see
a bright future in the long run.
Once again,
I'll repeat the significance of a diversified portfolio. If
we sit on one egg and that egg breaks, we're going to be in
a tough spot (even if it's a chocolate egg). Don't get me
wrong, although diversification is not deemed as protection
against bankruptcies it does limit your exposure in a particular
investment.
Until
next week,
Linda Goin
|