|
Lately,
the stock market climate has been conducive to research new
investments. Nothing out there is flying so high that we fall
over backwards watching it, to be sure. Other than some mild
irritation at being bamboozled by a few corporate executives,
most women I've talked to lately are ok with their portfolio
choices. When we have time, we still look for solid investments.
No, I
don't hang around with Wall St. professionals. The women I
talk to are just average folks. These women are teachers,
students, retail personnel, some writers, a lot of artist-types,
and mothers. None of us are Nobel Prize winners, and most
of us experience our fair share of chaos. Our time is limited.
If we sneeze wrong, a whole day could be shot.
Corporate
executives know this about us. Their marketing teams tell
them how busy we are. These marketing teams also have access
to math wizards, word masters, and money. The combination
of these ingredients can make for a pretty scary stew.
For example:
Let's say you find a company that appears to have fairly strong
financials. You've been watching this stock for a while (every
day while you brush your teeth in front of CNN), and nothing
seems abnormal. At work one day, you scan a story in a newspaper
found in the break room. The news blurb is about the company
you've been investigating. You check the date on the paper
to make sure it's not old news, and you read the story again:
Fairy
Tale Company Creates New Treatment for Chaos
Somewhere,
USA, Right Now - Frankly Benign, spokesperson and CEO
for Fairy Tale Company (FATACO), today announced a new treatment
for chaos.
"We've
tested this treatment," Benign stated, "And it's better
than any treatment for chaos on the market today."
This test
was recently conducted on 200 women. Ninety-five women were
given old treatments for chaos, and 105 women were given
the new Fairy Tale treatment for chaos. After four weeks
of treatment, Benign introduced the following results at
a news conference this morning.
"Among
women with mild forms of chaos, 20 received the old treatment,
and 85 received the new treatment,"Benign
said. "Among the 20 receiving the old treatment, 4 were
cured, for a 20% cure rate. Among the 85 receiving our new
treatment, 25 were cured, for a cure rate of 29.4%."
Benign
continued, "Among women with severe cases of chaos, 75 received
the old treatment, and 20 received the new treatment. Among
the 75 receiving the old treatment, 35 were cured, for a
46.7% cure rate. Among the 20 receiving our new treatment,
12 were cured for a 60% cure rate."
Benign
added, "Obviously our new cure is a landmark achievement
for both mild and severe forms of chaos. We're very pleased
with the results. Women everywhere should rejoice."
Fairy
Tale Company's stock soared this morning on the news. Benign
sees no end to the market for this powerful new treatment.
You
fly out of the break room and slam into the chair at your
computer. You navigate with the speed of a racehorse around
that final bend to BUYandHOLD. Fortunately, you already signed
up for the new Streaming
Stock Portfolio. You have access to up-to-the minute quotes
on FATACO in real time.
Sure
enough, FATACO has jumped, and so do you. You glance at your
stopwatch, and realize you have time to make that trade window
at BUYandHOLD. You go for it. Yes! 100 shares of FATACO in
record time! You call Fairy Tale Company direct and order
a case of this new treatment for yourself.
You
shouldn't have bothered. Really. You already got the treatment
when you jumped the gun on that stock purchase. Let's slow
down and crunch the numbers in that news story again?
The
old treatment was given to a total of 95 women. Out of this
number, 39 were cured. That's 4 out of 20 with mild forms
of chaos, and 35 out of 75 with severe cases of chaos. The
overall cure rate was really 39/95, or 41%.
The
new treatment was given to a total of 105 women. Out of this
number, 37 were cured. That's 25 out of 85 with mild forms
of chaos, and 12 out of 20 with severe cases of chaos. The
overall cure rate for the new treatment was really 37/105,
or 35.2%.
Something
look funny? It should. The old treatment for chaos (whatever
that is) still works better - overall - than the new treatment.
By
the time you figure this out, Fairy Tale stock has packed
its bags and gone south. Other folks with more time on their
hands knew people would jump on the news story bandwagon.
I don't think I need to expound on this scenario. Hopefully,
you know by now what happens to pumped-up stocks.
How
can this deceitful thing happen, you ask? Well, for one reason,
because it can. The logical reason is that the use of statistics
based on two unequally numbered comparison groups, rather
than statistics based on an overall situation, can often be
prettier for sales. Although the company used perfectly legitimate
numbers, they've skewed them to their advantage.
How
can you stop this from happening to you? When you see figures
comparing two groups, especially groups consisting of uneven
numbers, slow down. Pull out your trusty calculator and add
those groups up. You could save yourself mucho time and money.
This
practice happens often, but don't blame the newspaper. Most
newspaper offices can make your life look like a vacation
on a slow boat to Paradise. In fact, if you call the editor
and let them know what you just discovered, they may thank
you profusely. You may have given them a great story, lady.
That's better than a whole bunch of Fairy Tale.
Until Next Week,
Linda Goin
|